Farming in S. Africa, A Different Reality

Screen Shot 2018-03-30 at 4.09.22 PM.png

On left is Sonny Perdue, 31st U.S. Secretary of Agriculture and Georgia farmer. On right is Charles Back, S. African farmer who survived a brutal attack on his farm last month and one of hundreds of S. African farmers attacked and murdered each year. Each man represents very different realities as farmers in their respective lands. Read more about Back’s attack.

Farming. What do you think of? Amber waves of grain? OshKosh B’gosh overall-clad children rolling in hay? The pitchfork-in-hand puritanically dressed couple of Grant Wood’s American Gothic? A pastoral way of life?

Screen Shot 2018-03-30 at 2.17.34 PM

American Gothic (1930), painting by Grant Wood, Art Institute of Chicago

On a recent trip to South Africa, I learned farming had a different look. There, farming looked like 10-foot chain-link fences topped with razor sharp barbed wire as far as the eye can see. It was attack dogs who look like they’d just as soon take a chunk out of your thigh as look at you. And it was ubiquitous security gates, guards and cameras. It was fear.

Screen Shot 2018-03-30 at 3.51.42 PM.png

Typical fencing found around South African farms.

Why? Because farming in South Africa is the most dangerous job in the world.1 Not by the way we Americans consider farming dangerous. Not by accidents caused while working with hazardous equipment like combines, or by toxic chemicals or from tractor overturns. This was danger in the form of murder.

According to the UK’s Daily Mail, South African farmers are twice as likely to be murdered than police and are killed four times the rate of the community as a whole. In a 2017 debate in South Africa’s parliament, the attacks were described as “extremely violent and often accompanied by brutal torturing in the most barbaric way.” These acts also don’t take into account the all-too-frequent “indirect acts” against farmers, such as intimidation, arson and malicious damage to property, which are included in a 2016 police presentation in parliament.

So as our VALOR cohort visited farm after farm during our two-week educational tour, we repeatedly asked ourselves, “How can the people who produce food to feed hungry mouths be such a reviled target for so many?”

We learned the answer, as it is so often, is deep-rooted, multi-faceted and steeped in history.

Like many things in South Africa, the problem can be examined by looking how it affects the white population (9.1%) and the black (76.4%) and colored (8.9%)2, with some causes unique to each and others transcending both.

Let’s start with common causes. Crime is a huge problem in South Africa, as we learned. And crimes against farms, usually in the form of crop or livestock theft, are common. Many farmers are simply attacked when they try to deter a crime in action.

Then there’s jealousy. Not my word, but theirs. When we met with Solomon Maseou, an emerging black farmer in the Free State Provence, he explained that his neighbors get jealous when he appears more successful than them. Many of his neighbors are homeless or un- or under-employed, so appearing more successful is not very difficult. In situations like this—whether the target of jealousy is a white farmer or a black farmer like Solomon—violence, theft and destruction of property often results.

Screen Shot 2018-03-30 at 3.05.52 PM.png

South Africa’s landscape is populated with underserved informal settlements and townships like this one named Kayamandi, which  sits adjacent to productive Stellenbosch farm land (on the horizon in the photo). VALOR visited both the township and the nearby farms to get multiple perspectives on living in this rich agricultural province.

And lastly, there’s the hot-button topic…land reform, also known as land re-appropriation or expropriation. In December 2017 the governing African National Congress party and in turn Parliament, gave a nod to land expropriation without compensation. According to Bloomburg News, this will result in “…redistributing land to the country’s black majority from the more affluent white minority….”3

Screen Shot 2018-03-30 at 2.38.13 PM.png

Andrew Cloete, a black emerging farmer VALOR visited with in the Western Cape Provence who farms with apples, pears, sheep, cattle and cash crops (barley and oats). In 2008, the South African government gave him the farm, now called “Kleineseljagt.”

This is an issue because under the rule of European colonists, South Africa’s Natives Land Act of 1913 stripped most black people of their right to own property, a policy reinforced decades later by the National Party and its system of apartheid, or apartness. A government land audit released last month showed that farms and agricultural holdings comprise 97 percent of the 121.9 million hectares of the nation’s area, and that whites own 72 percent of the 37 million hectares held by individuals.4 So to rectify past wrongs and to make more equitable the current distribution of land, government has concluded that it will seize land from white farmers without compensation and give it to black farmers.

Screen Shot 2018-03-30 at 2.52.49 PM.png

Cornel van Rensburg of Langplaas Vegetable Farm says of the dangers of farming and the possibility of his farm being taken from him without compensation, “It’s in God’s hands.” Langplaas is a 4th generation farm of approximately 1,236 acres of irrigated lands, specializing in butternuts, garden beet, carrots, sweet potatoes and onions. They have a state of the art packing house, cooling facilities and a hydro cooling system on the farm.

This violence has ripple effects back home, as well.

According to Newsweek5, more than 12,000 people have signed a petition calling for U.S. President Donald Trump to allow white South African landowners, who have their land stripped as a result of the country’s expropriation vote, to immigrate to our country. The petition calls on Trump to “take the steps necessary to initiate an emergency immigration plan allowing white Boers to come to the United States.” Boer is the term used to describe South Africans of Dutch, German or Huguenot descent, and who are also commonly referred to as Afrikaners. The petition from white South African farmers also urges Trump to stop admitting refugees from Somalia and the Middle East, because they “cannot be properly vetted,” and instead welcome white South Africans into the U.S. The petition explains that white South Africans “can be easily vetted and also possess skills that make them compatible with our culture and civilization,” the petition says.

So, as we learned through our international VALOR seminar in South Africa, a career in farming takes on different perspectives, including different risks, depending where on the globe you stand. There are, of course similarities that we heard. Securing good labor and farm loans, especially for emerging farmers, was a constant issue for South African farmers, like us. There, like here, consumers now think their food comes from grocery stores instead of farms. And farming continues to be a family affair regardless of what hemisphere the farm is in.

But despite visiting countless farms in Virginia in our first 10 VALOR sessions, I can assure you murder, torture, rape, and arson were not words that were part of any dialogue we had with farmers on U.S. soils. It was only through our international VALOR seminar that we were enlightened (and disheartened) to see that it was elsewhere and that agriculture does, indeed, look differently depending on where you stand.

Notes

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5534449/South-Africas-white-farmers-likely-killed-police.html

2Population figures are from the 2011 census. (http://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/south-africa-population/)

3 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-20/south-africa-s-anc-agrees-to-push-constitutional-change-on-land

4 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-01/why-land-seizure-is-back-in-news-in-south-africa-quicktake-q-a

5 http://www.newsweek.com/thousands-sign-petition-asking-trump-allow-white-people-south-africa-migrate-826126

More information and statistics on farm attacks:

2 thoughts on “Farming in S. Africa, A Different Reality

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s